Old Town Pizza

Reviews

• Jay Y.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  Stopped by here for lunch after hiking around Lake Clementine. Ordered a family size pizza (20", $36), with half doc's chicken and half mother lode.
  
  Pizza came out in about ~20 minutes and it was enough to feed our group of 4. Personally I liked the doc's chicken better of the two, and the pizza did not disappoint! Flavor was on point, cheesy was gooey, and the crust was crispy - everything I look for in a pizza.
  
  Parking was not too bad, we did street parking about a blockish away across from the old courthouse. Staff was friendly, we sat outside and ate next to their cool painting
  
  Would definitely come back here again if I'm in the area

• Russ D.

  star star star star_border star_border 5 June 2026

  @OldTownPizza Slow service. Not exactly under staffed on a Monday summer evening. Took quite a long time to get the water beverages after the legnthy wait to be seated. A lot of smiling and chatting staff in the background.
  
  Was told the white sauce calzone was delicious. I ordered it. It lacked sufficient sauce. The crust was good. It was hearty and stuffed with toppings.
  
  The veggie pizza was large with a lot of veggies. The veggies were piled high. But they were undercooked. The pieces of veggies were so huge that they just didn't cook fully.
  
  We were famished and ate it because what other option did we have?
  
  Overall my experience here was mediocre at best. Maybe it was an off day. Maybe since it was close to closing things were wonky. We finished our meal three and a half minutes before they closed.
  
  Try it once. You'll be maybe glad you did.

• T S.

  star star star star star 31 May 2026

  My buddy and I were in the area for business.  Our customer recommended this place and they were correct.
  We starts with Caprese and Caesar salad, both were good.  My friend was eager to try the bread sticks and they were great.
  
  We shared a large Mother load pizza and it was awesome... lots of toppings and the crust was spot on.
  
  Service was good and I liked the ambiance. If you are looking for pizza in the area , you need to drop in.

• Josh G.

  star star star star star 27 May 2026

  Super cool, great vibes pizza spot.  Stopped by here after a Spartan Race in Tahoe for a celebratory pizza and beer on our way back to Sac town. Ambiance was a 10+, pizza and dough was solid!!! And they have a rotating taps list. Stepping into old town felt like we took a small trip back in time to get some world class pizza n beer.

• Charlie W.

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  DELICIOUS!!!!
  I've heard a lot about this place and they were all right. This is the best pizza we've had since we moved here.   We had the Motherlode with the creamy garlic white sauce and standard pepperoni it they were great.    It's a little spendy with a medium pizza setting you back about $19.00.  Great customer service.  Sergio and Donte were awesome.  They were pretty busy when we went in but got our order quickly.  They actually made a mistake on one of the orders so remade it for free and threw beers our way making us happy to wait for the other pie.  Put the others on the oven to keep them warm while the other pie cooked.  I really like all the old pictures of Auburn and funny signs.  Lots to look at and the setting was great.  We ordered takeout but I think next time we'll dine in.  Wasn't too loud and the booths look pretty private.  Great selection of local beers which is always a plus.